Are Private Schools Safer Than Public Schools?

Are Private Schools Safer Than Public Schools?

Wednesday, 01 May 2024 18:04

There are a multitude of concerns parents must answer when considering school choices for their children. From curricula to athletics to class size, we want to know everything about every institution before we enroll our little ones. It is deeply troubling that one of those questions is whether a private school is safer than public institutions. 

Even though school violence is in the news cycle too often, it is, fortunately, statistically unlikely for your children to experience it. Nevertheless, there are other metrics for  measuring, and parents should be made aware of them.

Generally speaking, your child's school is a safe place, whether it is private or public; however, private schools are measurably safer. In this article, we are discussing what you need to know about private and public school safety.

Private Schools Are Indeed Statistically Safer Than Public Schools

Public and private schools alike are wholly committed to providing safe environments for students to learn and teachers to invest in the lives of students. They have all spent countless hours investing in safety policies that help facilitate peace and harmony. 

Unfortunately, however, it can be difficult to maintain the level of safety they desire. Nevertheless, it is important to note that private schools are statistically safer than public schools.

Key Statistics Regarding School Safety:

Instances of violence:

  • Fortunately, any single school experiencing an active shooter situation is statistically improbable. Just 0.001% of schools have experienced such a situation in the last two decades. Of course, even one is too many.
  • 94% of active shooter situations since 2000 have taken place at public institutions.
  • 20% of public school students say there are gangs on campus. 2% of private school students report the presence of gangs.

Instances of bullying:

  • Percentage of students who report being bullied: 28% Public, 21% Private
  • Percentage of students who report being made fun of: 18% Public, 14% Private
  • Percentage of students who report being the subject of rumors: 19% Public, 13% Private
  • Percentage of students who report being pushed, shoved, tripped, or spit upon: 8% Public, 5% Private

Trouble for teachers:

  • 10% of Public teachers have been threatened, and 6% have been harmed by students.
  • 3% of private school teachers report threats or physical violence.
  • More than 40% of public school teachers say that they are dealing with instances of behavior problems that interfere with teaching. Meanwhile, only 22% of private school teachers report the same.

Why Are Private Schools Safer?

There is not one single answer to why private schools are safer than public institutions; however, there are several contributing factors. We have identified 16 key reasons private schools are safer. 

1) Private Schools Have Smaller Class Sizes

Public school classrooms might have 30 or more students, whereas at St. Paul Lutheran School in Northville, we ensure that no class exceeds 20 students. This smaller class size allows for a more personalized educational experience, giving teachers ample opportunity to engage with each student. 

Such an environment not only enhances individual learning but also helps teachers to quickly identify any academic or emotional challenges students might face. By addressing these challenges promptly, teachers can provide appropriate interventions that foster a supportive learning atmosphere, ultimately guiding students toward Christ-like solutions and encouraging their overall development.

2) Private Schools Are Safer Places For Discussion

In private schools like St. Paul Lutheran School in Northville, the smaller student-to-teacher ratio creates a safer environment for open discussions. With more individual attention, students are encouraged to express their thoughts and participate in dialogues without the fear of being overlooked or marginalized. 

This nurturing setting fosters a sense of security among students, making it easier for them to raise questions and explore new ideas. Such a dynamic is crucial for intellectual growth and helps build confidence in young learners, ensuring they feel valued and heard in their educational journey.

3) Private Schools Often Have Small Student Bodies

The relatively smaller size of student bodies in private schools like ours significantly enhances the effectiveness of mentoring programs. With fewer students to manage, school counselors and administrators can devote more time to each student, providing tailored guidance and support. 

This close monitoring allows for a more responsive educational environment, where potential issues can be addressed proactively and students' individual needs are met more efficiently. This intimate setting not only helps in academic and personal development but also strengthens the community feeling within the school.

4) Private Schools Promote A Biblical Worldview

biblical worldview

At St. Paul Lutheran School in Northville, we integrate a biblical worldview into our curriculum, which teaches students to see the world through a Christ-like lens. This approach not only enhances their academic learning but also molds their social interactions and personal values. 

Recognizing fellow students and teachers as created in the image of God instills a profound respect for humanity. This foundation is crucial for developing moral character and ethical behavior, ensuring that students not only excel academically but also grow into compassionate and principled individuals.

5) Private Schools Often Emphasize The Gospel

The gospel's presence in our curriculum is central to our educational philosophy. It demonstrates to each student how much Jesus loves them, thereby helping them to recognize their own intrinsic value.

 This understanding fosters healthy self-esteem and encourages students to treat others with kindness and respect. Such spiritual nurturing goes beyond mere academic education, as it equips students with the moral compass necessary to navigate life's challenges in a Christ-honoring way.

6) Private Schools Often Emphasize Christ’s Teaching

Our school places a strong emphasis on the teachings of Christ, which instructs students to love both their neighbors and their enemies and to act kindly towards those who may oppose them. 

By allowing the freedom to discuss and emphasize these teachings, we utilize the Bible not only as a historical and religious document but also as a practical guide in daily living. This unique aspect of our education helps students apply Christian principles in real-life scenarios, promoting a life of service, integrity, and love toward God and our neighbors.

7) Private Schools Promote Comprehensive Safety Measures 

Private schools implement a broad range of safety measures that go beyond the basic protocols found in many public schools. These measures often include advanced security systems, such as surveillance cameras, controlled access points, and regular safety drills that keep both students and staff prepared for various emergencies. 

These systems are regularly updated to incorporate new technology and strategies to ensure the highest level of safety.

8) Private Schools Have Enhanced Communication Systems

Communication is key to maintaining a safe school environment. Private schools often have the advantage of smaller communities, which facilitates faster and more effective communication between parents, teachers, and administration. 

This close-knit communication network ensures that all parties are informed about any issues that might affect student safety and allows for quick responses to any potential problems.

9) Private Schools Often Provide Specialized Training For Staff

Teachers and staff at private schools typically receive specialized training in conflict resolution, emergency response, and even basic first aid and mental health first aid. This training ensures that they are not only equipped to deal with academic challenges but can also effectively handle situations that might pose safety risks to the students.

10) Private Schools Promote A Positive School Culture

A significant aspect of safety in private schools is the emphasis on creating a positive school culture that promotes respect, responsibility, and kindness. 

This culture is often built around a core set of values or a religious foundation, which helps students develop moral grounding and respect for themselves and others. In such environments, bullying and violence are less likely to occur, and when they do, they are swiftly addressed.

11) Private Schools Welcome Parental Involvement

Private schools often have higher levels of parental involvement, which is a key factor in maintaining safety. Parents are more likely to be engaged in school activities and decision-making processes, providing an additional layer of oversight and involvement that contributes to the overall security and effectiveness of school safety measures.

12) Private Schools Often Have Tailored Counseling And Support Services

With smaller student bodies, private schools can offer more tailored counseling and support services. This personalized approach not only helps in addressing academic and social challenges but also plays a crucial role in mitigating issues related to mental health and emotional well-being, which are critical components of a safe, educational environment.

13) Private Schools Safety Through Academic And Spiritual Education

At institutions like St. Paul Lutheran School in Northville, safety is also fostered through the curriculum and spiritual teachings. The integration of academic learning with spiritual growth creates a holistic environment where students are taught to value and care for each other.

Our teachers believe each student is a Child of God gifted with the potential to achieve success. Lessons in empathy, compassion, and ethical behavior are intertwined with regular academic subjects, reinforcing the importance of these values in everyday life.

14) Private Schools Are Committed To Safety Policies And Procedures

Detailed safety policies and procedures are a staple in private schools. These policies are not only comprehensive but are also regularly reviewed and revised to adapt to new challenges and ensure they meet the needs of all students and staff. This ongoing commitment to safety is fundamental in maintaining the trust of parents and the well-being of students.

15) Private Schools Practice Crisis Management And Response

Crisis management and response capabilities are other areas in which private schools often excel. With dedicated resources and trained personnel, these schools are prepared to handle emergencies with efficiency and calm. Regular training and drills ensure that everyone knows their role during a crisis, significantly reducing the risk of panic and confusion.

16) Private Schools Build A Safe Educational Ecosystem

Ultimately, the safety measures in private schools contribute to building a safe, educational ecosystem that supports students' academic and personal growth. This ecosystem is characterized by strong leadership, committed teachers, supportive parents, and responsible students, all working together towards a common goal of creating a safe and nurturing learning environment.

Consider Private School In Northville, MI

While all schools strive to provide a safe environment, private schools like St. Paul Lutheran Northville have distinct advantages that often make them safer. 

Their ability to implement comprehensive safety measures, coupled with a strong community and a focus on character development, creates a secure atmosphere where children can excel both academically and personally. For parents considering the best educational path for their children, understanding these aspects of private school safety can be crucial in making an informed decision.

There are several reasons beyond these that explain why private schools are statistically safer environments for learning than public institutions. Private schools like St. Paul Lutheran School in Northville, MI, don’t just put an emphasis on physical safety, we are also committed to being a safe place for students to grow spiritually. 

If you have more questions regarding school safety, want to discuss our safety policies, or just want to know more about St. Paul Lutheran School in Northville, we are here to help. Please contact St. Paul Lutheran in Northville for more information.