skip to main content
How Private Schooling vs. Public Influences Students’ Future Family Lives

In today's educational landscape, parents face numerous choices that will shape not only their children's academic future but their personal development as well. One of the most significant decisions is whether to choose private Christian education or public schooling. While both options have their merits, research increasingly shows that the educational environment we choose for our children has far-reaching effects that extend well beyond graduation day—influencing their future family lives in profound ways.

1. The Foundation of Values Education

The alignment between home and school values creates a powerful foundation for children's future family lives. When children experience consistent messaging about values, beliefs, and worldview, they develop a stronger sense of identity and purpose.

Research demonstrates that religiously committed families show significant benefits in family life. According to studies reviewed by Dollahite and Thatcher, "religious practices are linked with family satisfaction, closer father-child relationships, and closer parent-child relationships." Additionally, "religious involvement promotes involved and responsible fathering and is associated with more involved mothering." (Dollahite & Thatcher, The Sutherland Institute, 2005)

At St. Paul Lutheran School, we understand that values education isn't just about teaching rules—it's about forming character that lasts a lifetime. Our Christ-centered curriculum integrates biblical principles throughout every subject area, reinforcing the values many families already teach at home.

Public schools, by comparison, must maintain religious neutrality, which often means values education is either absent or presented without a faith foundation. While many public school teachers are dedicated professionals who care deeply about character formation, the institutional limitations prevent them from addressing values from a religious perspective.

The consistency of values education between home and school creates a powerful reinforcement that shapes how children view family relationships, commitment, and moral responsibility—all of which directly impact their future family lives.

2. Community Connections and Their Long-term Impact

The school community significantly influences how children understand and value relationships, directly affecting their future approach to family life.

Research from the Search Institute's Effective Christian Education Study found that family religiousness was the most important factor in faith maturity. The study discovered that youth in families that often express faith are three times more likely to participate in family projects to help others and twice as likely to spend time helping other people than youth from families that did not express faith. (Benson & Eklin, Search Institute, 1990)

Private Christian schools like St. Paul Lutheran foster deep community connections through:

  • Smaller class sizes that enable more meaningful relationships
  • Multi-generational events that connect families across age groups
  • Shared faith commitments that strengthen bonds between families
  • Parent involvement opportunities that model community engagement

These community experiences teach children that families don't function in isolation but thrive when connected to a supportive community. Public schools often have larger student populations and more limited opportunities for faith-based community connections, which can affect how children view the role of community in family life.

As researcher Robert Wuthnow discovered in his study "Growing Up Religious," effective religious socialization happens through "embedded practices" that are "firmly intertwined with the daily habits of family routines, of eating and sleeping, of having conversations, of adorning spaces in which people live, of celebrating the holidays, and of being part of a community." He notes that "compared with these practices, the formal teachings of religious leaders often pale in significance." (Wuthnow, Growing Up Religious, Beacon Press, 1999)

The community connections formed during the school years often become lifelong relationships that support families through challenges and celebrations, creating models for children's future family lives.

3. Academic Excellence and Family Prosperity

The connection between academic preparation and future family stability is well-established. Students who receive excellent academic preparation are better positioned for career success, financial stability, and the ability to provide for their families.

Private Christian schools like St. Paul Lutheran maintain high academic standards while integrating faith throughout the curriculum. Our smaller class sizes allow for individualized attention, helping each student reach their full academic potential.

Research by Search Institute reveals that youth in families where faith is often expressed are twice as likely to "read the Bible and prayer when alone; read and study about the Christian faith; are spiritually moved by the beauty of God's creation; and have often felt God's presence in their life." These practices contribute to overall well-being and stability that benefit family life. (Search Institute, Effective Christian Education Study)

While academic excellence can certainly be achieved in public schools, private Christian education offers the added benefit of connecting academic achievement to spiritual purpose. Students learn that their talents and abilities are God-given gifts to be used in service to others—a perspective that shapes how they approach work and family responsibilities later in life.

4. Faith Integration and Future Family Choices

Perhaps the most direct influence of private Christian education on future family life comes through the integration of faith into every aspect of learning and school community.

Christian Smith's National Study on Youth and Religion found that "the single most important social influence on the religious and spiritual lives of adolescents is their parents." The study revealed that "of parents who report that their faith is extremely important in their daily lives, 67 percent of their teens report that faith is extremely or very important in their daily lives." (Smith & Denton, Soul Searching, Oxford University Press, 2005)

At St. Paul Lutheran School, we partner with parents to reinforce faith formation, creating a powerful combination that shapes children's understanding of:

  • Marriage as a covenant commitment
  • Parenting as a sacred responsibility
  • Family as a place where faith is lived and shared
  • Reconciliation and forgiveness as essential family practices

Research by David Dollahite and Loren Marks identified eight processes that highly religious families engage in: "Turning to God for support, guidance and strength; sanctifying the family by living religion at home; resolving conflict with prayer, repentance, and forgiveness; serving others in the family and faith community; overcoming challenges and trials through shared faith; abstaining from proscribed activities and substances; sacrificing time, money, comfort, and convenience for religious reasons; and nurturing spiritual growth through example, teaching, and discussion." (Dollahite & Marks, Sourcebook on Family Theories and Methods, 2005)

These faith practices, reinforced through private Christian education, provide children with models and skills that directly benefit their future family relationships.

5. Making the Right Educational Choice for Your Family's Future

When considering the long-term impact of educational choices on your child's future family life, here are key factors to consider:

  1. Values alignment: Does the school reinforce or contradict the values you're teaching at home?

  2. Community quality: What type of peer and family community will surround your child during their formative years?

  3. Whole-person development: Does the school address spiritual and character formation alongside academic excellence?

  4. Faith integration: Will your child learn to connect faith with everyday decisions and relationships?

  5. Family involvement: Does the school value and support parental involvement in education?

At St. Paul Lutheran School, we understand that today's educational choices shape tomorrow's families. Our approach to education nurtures not only academic excellence but also the faith foundation and character development that lead to strong, loving families in the future.

FAQ About Private Education's Impact on Family Life

How does private Christian education influence children's future marriage choices?

Students in Christian schools are more likely to develop a faith-based understanding of marriage as a covenant commitment. Research shows that "divorce rates are lower and marital satisfaction and quality scores highest among religiously involved couples," suggesting that the values reinforced in Christian education contribute to stronger marriages later in life. (Mahoney et al., Journal of Family Psychology, 2001)

Will private school education prepare my child for "real world" family challenges?

Yes. Christian education doesn't shield children from challenges but equips them with faith-based resources to face them. Studies show that "greater religiosity in parents and youth is associated with a variety of protective factors for adolescents," including tools for addressing family conflicts in healthy ways. (Smith & Denton, Soul Searching, Oxford University Press, 2005)

How does private education influence parenting styles in the next generation?

Students who receive Christian education often develop an understanding of parenting as a sacred calling rather than just a role. Research indicates that "religious involvement promotes involved and responsible fathering and is associated with more involved mothering," suggesting that the values learned in Christian schools positively influence future parenting approaches. (Wilcox, W.B., Sacred Vows, Public Purposes, 2005)

Does attending a private Christian school make students more likely to raise their own children in faith?

While there are no guarantees, research from the National Study on Youth and Religion suggests a strong correlation. Christian Smith writes, "We'll get what we are," meaning that "by normal processes of socialization, and unless other significant forces intervene, most parents most likely will end up getting religiously of their children what they themselves are." Private Christian education helps students develop the knowledge and practices to share faith with the next generation. (Smith & Denton, Soul Searching, Oxford University Press, 2005)

How do private Christian schools support family formation in today's challenging cultural environment?

Christian schools provide counter-cultural messages about family, marriage, and parenting that are rooted in biblical principles rather than shifting cultural trends. According to researchers Dollahite and Thatcher, "one of the most important things parents can do for their children is spiritual and religious experience and community" - something Christian schools help facilitate. (Dollahite & Thatcher, The Sutherland Institute, 2005)

Is the investment in private education worth it when considering its impact on future family life?

Many families find that the long-term benefits to their children's character formation, faith development, and relationship skills make private Christian education a valuable investment. As Smith's research indicates, "Parents for whom religious faith is quite important are thus likely to be raising teenagers for whom faith is quite important," creating an intergenerational benefit that extends to future families. (Smith & Denton, Soul Searching, Oxford University Press, 2005)

Conclusion

The choice between private Christian and public education extends far beyond academics—it influences the very fabric of our children's future family lives. By choosing an educational environment that reinforces faith, values, and character development, parents provide their children with tools and models that will shape their approach to marriage, parenting, and family relationships for years to come.

At St. Paul Lutheran School, we're committed to partnering with parents to provide education that nurtures not just successful students but future family leaders who will create homes where faith, love, and service thrive. We invite you to explore how our educational approach can benefit not just your child but generations to come.

To learn more about St. Paul Lutheran School and our approach to education that shapes future families, contact our admissions office today.